Monday, Nov. 22, 2004
Japan is becoming impatient with demands that it should constantly apologize for what happened more than 60 years ago
BY JIM FREDERICK | TOKYO

| KATSUMI KASAHARA / AP |
| HONOR Koizumi's regular trips to the Yasukuni Shrine feed anti-Japanese sentiment abroad |
|
It's nine o'clock on a Thursday night, and six friends from Tokyo's Keio University are sharing a few beers and many plates of Okinawan-style food at a bar in the Azabu-Juban neighborhood. They are all currently students in Professor Ryosei Kokubun's seminar on modern Chinese politics, so the conversation is focused, as it often is, on the complex relationship between Japan and its giant neighbor to the west.
Yuji Hashiguchi, 21, says that when growing up, he was profoundly influenced by the beauty of classical Chinese literature and captivated by the stories his grandmother would tell of the time she spent in China before and during World War II, when his grandfather worked for a firm associated with the South Manchurian Railway Co. Hashiguchi knows all about the atrocities committed in China by Japan during that period, but he has always been inspired by his grandmother's love for the country and its people. "My grandmother told me the Chinese were always very nice to them," he says. "When there wasn't enough food, the Chinese shared with them the little that they had." He strikes the most conciliatory note among the group, decrying Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi's visits to the Yasukuni Shrine. Hashiguchi says that better relations between the two countries are not just possible, but with a little work, highly likely. "Most people in China have goodwill toward the Japanese," he says. "But the Chinese are a very proud people, and the Japanese scarred their pride by invading. We need to be sensitive about that."
It's a nice sentiment, but it isn't universally shared. Hashiguchi's classmate Kenji Sato, 21, allows that the Chinese individually may be wonderful people, but thinks that the two countries' attitudes toward each other make them virtually destined for friction. And he is skeptical that political tensions are going to ease anytime soon, because he believes the very foundation of Chinese identity is now tied to being anti-Japanese. "I think that even if the Communist Party loses power, the next regime will still remain anti-Japan," he declares.
Hashiguchi and Sato—and their equally well-educated, opinionated friends—are a microcosm of Japan's younger generation and the highly conflicted, often contradictory attitudes it harbors toward China. Nearly 60 years after the end of World War II, Japanese youth are witnessing what they believe is a dramatic shift in power, as the political and economic momentum (to say nothing of military might) in Asia swings inexorably from Tokyo to Beijing. Yet even as they acknowledge that China is the ascendant force of the 21st century, many resent what they describe as China's insistence that they answer for issues they believe should long have been consigned to history.
True, within Japan there is no certain consensus on attitudes to China. Some agree that Japan has never properly atoned for its brutal occupation of much of Asia, but others are exasperated with what they see as Beijing's cynical leveraging of the issue for political and economic gain. For all those who do not support Koizumi's regular visits to the Yasukuni Shrine, there are others who dislike what they see as China's gall in presuming to tell Japan's Prime Minister what he can do in his own country. Some argue against a revision of Japan's pacifist constitution; others become apoplectic at Chinese accusations that "militarism" is on the rise in democratic, nuclear weapon-free Japan, when China is estimated to outspend Japan on defense by up to $20 billion a year. Many acknowledge that the Japanese school system has a tendency to whitewash unsavory events in history, but other Japanese have begun to look with anxiety at China's "patriotic education" program. These issues go beyond college bull sessions. They reach up to the very highest levels of both governments. Increasingly, say analysts, the two great powers of Asia are missing the chance to determine how they plan to coexist in this new century.
While the Chinese and Japanese media whirl into a frenzy over everything from stray Chinese submarines in Japanese waters to stray Japanese sex tourists in China, one issue has become an emblem of impasse: Koizumi's visits to the Yasukuni Shrine. He has gone there four times in three-and-a-half years of his term, and each time China's government has expressed its dismay, calling the trips a hurtful homage to Japan's warmongering past. Japan has grown impatient with what it considers to be China's pathological nurturing of remote grievances. China, on the other hand, is infuriated by what it sees as Japan's haste to bury unexamined history. "The two sides have locked themselves into a position where they cannot bridge the gap," says Jeffrey Kingston, a professor of history at Temple University's Tokyo campus.
From the Japanese point of view, they have been talking into a void for years. Although Japan may not have reached out as contritely to its former enemies as Germany did following World War II, many Japanese insist that the dawn of the cold war, when Communist China and half of the Korean peninsula became its enemies again, constrained any attempts at coziness. Others maintain that Japan has apologized to China publicly and often, including Emperor Akihito's expression of "sadness" at a Chinese state dinner in 1992 for "an unfortunate period in which my country inflicted great suffering on the people of China." Younger Japanese freely and loudly claim they bear no responsibility for the sins of their fathers (if not grandfathers and great-grandfathers). Hiroshi Kaga, 22, an art student in Tokyo, says, "The war is very over. It has nothing to do with me or my generation, or even my parents' generation. What am I supposed to say about it? Apologize to the Chinese people for what happened 60 years ago? I think that's even more insulting."
It's not that Japan is free of radical nationalism. For every sincere expression of contrition for Japan's conduct in World War II, there have always been a headband-wearing revisionist or a bigoted old-boy politician ready to declare that the Nanjing Massacre never happened or that Korean comfort women were "volunteers." But in modern Japanese society, such voices are of increasingly marginalized fringe elements. Nowadays, Japan can debate issues like the role of its flag, the national anthem, the Emperor and the constitution in a way that it could not do so even 10 years ago. "Japan is at a shifting point," says Koji Murata, an assistant professor of diplomatic history at Doshisha University in Kyoto. "Changes both in Japan and global politics, as well as the flood of information, have made Japanese more practical and pushed them to re-examine their world in a different light."
For businessmen, anti-Japanese sentiment in China is particularly vexing. China trades more with Japan than with any other nation, and only Japan's trade with the U.S. is greater than that with China. But managers and investors fear that if things are left unchecked, what should be a solid and important economic partnership will be derailed. Japan's Nikkei Weekly business newspaper recently launched a special series called "Dark Clouds over China." Its first installment was headlined, "Anti-Japanese Sentiment Sours Business." Inside was chronicled the tale of a business boycott organized against Canon for launching a new digital camera in Japan on Sept. 18, the 73rd anniversary of the Mukden Incident, a railroad bombing Japan used as a justification for annexing Manchuria. (Canon pointed out that it releases more than 100 products a year, that the date was pure coincidence, and that the camera was not even introduced in the China market.) Masaki Yabuuchi, a senior analyst at the Japan External Trade Organization, says many Chinese consumers still believe that Japan sells its best goods domestically and passes off the shoddy stuff to China. Such conspiracy-laden complaints gain a following in China via the Internet, and eventually migrate to the general public. Yabuuchi says anti-Japanese sentiment in China is encouraged by senior Party officials, taught by teachers and internalized by students. "Ever since the 'patriotic education' campaign started, Chinese feelings toward Japan have worsened dramatically," he says.
Even if Sino-Japanese relations are at their lowest point in years, powerful forces on both sides of the Sea of Japan are rallying to ensure they do not deteriorate further. In October 2003, 15 academic, business and media leaders came together to relaunch the 21st Century Committee for Japan-China Friendship, a bilateral advisory board designed to promote dialogue and understanding. Co-chaired by Fuji Xerox chairman Yotaro Kobayashi and Zheng Bijian, the head of the China Reform Forum, a think tank, the group has held two meetings so far during which it discussed strategies for resolving historical grudges and increasing trust. Halfway across the globe, a foundation based at the University of Montana honoring former U.S. ambassador to Japan Mike Mansfield and his wife Maureen runs periodic three-day retreats that bring together six young people of influence from each country to discuss the two nations' different approaches to history and ways to overcome their persistent obstacles. Through repeated gatherings like these at every level of society, including more high school exchange programs, Japan and China have a genuine opportunity to build mutual understanding, say many experts.
But for those Japanese not involved in such exercises, incidents like the harassment of Japanese soccer fans at this year's Asian Cup final in Beijing carry more weight. Says Keio University student Sanae Takasugi, 21: "It came as a shock that anti-Japanese feelings in China could be so strong and massive. Whatever unfriendly feelings the Japanese may hold against the Chinese are completely different in scale compared with that of the Chinese. I think that caught the Japanese off guard." Shingo Nishida, 22, traveled to China to watch the Japanese team's games. He describes with a mixture of disbelief and sadness how he and his compatriots were booed and heckled every time the Japanese side played. "They were yelling, throwing their food and drinks at the Japanese fans," he says. "It wasn't a simple show of hostility. It was more complex than that. Was it Japan? Was it the heat of the moment? Was it soccer? I was there and I still don't know." And then he sums up perhaps the essence of young Japanese's feelings about China. "We need to stay respectful to the feelings of the Chinese, but I can't apologize for what happened. Instead of being tied to the past, why can't we start from the present and look ahead? Let it go."
With reporting by Hanna Kite and Toko Sekiguchi/Tokyo
From TIME Asia Magazine, issue dated November 29, 2004 / Vol. 164, No. 22